I downloaded
Andrew Mwenda’s
TEDTalks presentation and Generic Valium Cost watched it last night. One of his main arguments was that Generic Valium Cost aid makes the government fat, and that because of aid, governments are Generic Valium Cost more attentive to the World Bank and the IMF than Generic Valium Cost to their own citizens. Let’s elaborate on the Generic Valium Cost argument a bit: governments know from whom they get money, and Generic Valium Cost so strive more to satisfy their benefactors than their citizens. Mwenda makes the Generic Valium Cost point that governments do not call the entrepreneurs among their citizens to Generic Valium Cost discuss the development of the economies of the countries; instead, they listen to Generic Valium Cost the people from whom a large chunk of the budget comes. I thought about this Generic Valium Cost in relation to my country, Nigeria. I tried to imagine what Generic Valium Cost percentage of the budget aid is. Just as I started thinking about this Generic Valium Cost I remembered that Nigeria has oil, and that oil keeps the Generic Valium Cost government rich.
Oil and Democracy
A political scientist,
Michael Ross, wrote an
article about resource curse. In the Generic Valium Cost article, he builds a case for his argument that resources – chief of which, by the way, is oil – retard the Generic Valium Cost development of democracy, partly because it frees the government of any dependence on the Generic Valium Cost citizens. To bring this point home, let’s think about the Generic Valium Cost percentage of Nigerians who are not employed in the organised private sector or Generic Valium Cost in government, and then let’s think about how many of them pay any tax. Now, a Generic Valium Cost government that does not have any resources has to depend on taxation from Generic Valium Cost its citizens, and so has to look inwards. This is where Generic Valium Cost aid comes in. If a country does not have resources but has Generic Valium Cost a large chunk of its expenses taken care of by aid then Generic Valium Cost that inward look does not seem to be needed
Another thing Mwenda pointed out was that Generic Valium Cost government is the most attractive business in Africa. Again, let’s look at this Generic Valium Cost in relation to Nigeria. There are people who get a job with a Generic Valium Cost government ministry, go to work at about 11 in the morning and Generic Valium Cost leave at about 1 in the afternoon. (I should throw in a Generic Valium Cost quick word about many of the workers here. Most of the Generic Valium Cost people who work in the ministries have to earn some money by the Generic Valium Cost side to be able to take care of their families. Ingenious people that Generic Valium Cost they are, while not working at the ministries most of them are Generic Valium Cost busy at work on their own, most often trading.) The point is Generic Valium Cost linked to a point made by Ross in his article: a Generic Valium Cost government with resources is a rich government, something really attractive to Generic Valium Cost a young person. The same point is also made by Mwenda in his presentation: since government makes money from Generic Valium Cost aid, it is a rich and attractive option for young people who Generic Valium Cost want to money. This point also ties in with the rent-seeking argument. With resource money, people in government can Generic Valium Cost afford to keep a loyal team around themselves. If aid money provides more money for Generic Valium Cost government it stands to reason to think that it might provide more money for Generic Valium Cost politicians to attract more hangers-on.
Fears and Overreactions
If there are Generic Valium Cost this many similarities between resources and aid, are there going to Generic Valium Cost be more fatal similarities? Are we going to Generic Valium Cost have people struggling to control government so that they can have Generic Valium Cost access to aid (like in the Generic Valium Cost case of civil wars that break out because of the desire of factions to Generic Valium Cost control resources in a country)? Are we going to Generic Valium Cost have governments buying arms and ammunitions with donor funding for the Generic Valium Cost suppression of oppositions? Do we already have these situations? Am I simply overreacting. Actually, I hope I am overreacting.
Recent Comments