I was looking through my computer earlier today and buy ativan with mastercard I discovered a review I wrote during my first weeks as a buy ativan with mastercard Masters in Development Studies student at Uppsala in Sweden. The first thing those guys did was to buy ativan with mastercard encourage us to question the whole idea of development by making us read Gilbert Rist’s The History of Development: From Western Origins to Global Faith
. Below is a review I wrote of the book – an buy ativan with mastercard assignment. As I read through it today I strongly resisted the buy ativan with mastercard urge to edit my 24 year-old self, so excuse the sometimes flowery language.
Words, Spirits and History: A review of Gilbert Rist’s The History of Development
What is it with words? While some hardly make a buy ativan with mastercard sound others simply stand out, they call attention to themselves, beg to buy ativan with mastercard be heard. One of them is development. It is simply unimaginable that buy ativan with mastercard this word, and its most recent offsprings, human and sustainable development(s) should be buy ativan with mastercard subjected to as much rigorous examination and criticism as Gilbert Rist does in The History of Development. But the buy ativan with mastercard word is not what Rist battles with, it is the buy ativan with mastercard philosophy which gives the word life, which makes it relevant; it buy ativan with mastercard is the spirit which the word conjures, and the faith which it buy ativan with mastercard commands that necessitate such examination. Then, words have long had buy ativan with mastercard a way of creeping into our consciousness and dominating our imagination, but not without some aid. Rist set out to buy ativan with mastercard explain the process by which this word gained and kept prominence. Perhaps the buy ativan with mastercard first thing it would be good to know is that buy ativan with mastercard the word has an origin.
Even before opening the buy ativan with mastercard book we get an idea of where the word came from. From the buy ativan with mastercard subtitle of the book we have a vague idea of the buy ativan with mastercard word’s birthplace, but not its birth process. Rist traces the buy ativan with mastercard process by which development came to become the dominant paradigm of measuring relations between North and buy ativan with mastercard South, he shows that the word has its roots in Western consciousness. He goes as far as to buy ativan with mastercard Aristotle’s conception of nature as development in circles, i.e. as a buy ativan with mastercard series of beginnings and ends and new beginnings, to St Augustine’s view of history as eschatological as it buy ativan with mastercard is presumed to be linked to the Bible, and ultimately to buy ativan with mastercard Jean-Baptiste Say and his social evolutionists who saw the western world as the buy ativan with mastercard most advanced one because of its high level of production and buy ativan with mastercard consumption. Apart from this argument for the western world’s referencing of itself as the ideal, their defeat of “savage races” seemed to buy ativan with mastercard lend credence to social evolutionism. It seemed only sensible to conclude that buy ativan with mastercard the western human was the most advanced of humans. Of necessity, this buy ativan with mastercard set the stage for the next level in the development of the buy ativan with mastercard history of development: colonialism.
In the buy ativan with mastercard late nineteenth century, the savage needed protection, and guidance in utilising the buy ativan with mastercard abundance of natural resources which nature had deemed fit to thrust upon him, or buy ativan with mastercard so the colonialists say. It was a period in which global relations marched from buy ativan with mastercard conquered/ conqueror to savage/civilised, and so colonised/coloniser. Several arguments were used to buy ativan with mastercard convince the people of the nobility of the endeavour, one was economical and buy ativan with mastercard another was purely paternalistic. Who wouldn’t blame the buy ativan with mastercard civilised world if they failed to bring civilisation to the dark parts of the buy ativan with mastercard world? If some parts of the buy ativan with mastercard world were uncivilised it was only morally obligatory for the part that buy ativan with mastercard was to bring civilisation to the other part. But the dominant paradigm was soon to buy ativan with mastercard adopt a different, more portent and enduring concept, that of development.
Rist gives the buy ativan with mastercard birth of development as the time of President Harry Truman’s inaugural address. From that buy ativan with mastercard time on, the relationship of countries of the north and those of the buy ativan with mastercard south came to be defined by the level of development. The paradigm shifted from buy ativan with mastercard that of colonised/coloniser to underdeveloped/developed. The main problem of this buy ativan with mastercard distinction was its assumption that underdevelopment is a natural stage of humanity. It was not an buy ativan with mastercard effect but could only be the antecedent of the “developed” Northern world. It was as if the buy ativan with mastercard North could look at the South and see how it was before it buy ativan with mastercard was touched by development. This perception of things could absolve the buy ativan with mastercard North of any responsibility in making the South the way it buy ativan with mastercard was, as underdeveloped is an intransitive verb, it is not an buy ativan with mastercard effect but can only be affected. The peoples of the South were no buy ativan with mastercard longer viewed as individual nations with individual histories, they were simply underdeveloped countries; they were deprived of the buy ativan with mastercard privilege of having their situations explained by history and were instead described as the buy ativan with mastercard natural state of being that was embarrassing and so would have buy ativan with mastercard to be helped to the state of the industrialised countries. And the buy ativan with mastercard way to do this was given as increasing the GDP. Perhaps we should say a buy ativan with mastercard little about Rostow’s proposition and his stages of economic growth.
Rostow’s recommendation for buy ativan with mastercard economic growth underlines an assumption that is an offspring of the buy ativan with mastercard development paradigm. Since it is believed that underdevelopment is a buy ativan with mastercard natural state from which the developed countries rose, it was only natural to buy ativan with mastercard presume that to effect development all one had to do was to buy ativan with mastercard follow the steps through which the North rose and then buy ativan with mastercard development would necessarily arrive in the underdeveloped regions. Rostow’s scale of development then buy ativan with mastercard starts with the underdeveloped stage, a natural state in which development is buy ativan with mastercard lacking and which has to proceed to the stage in which the buy ativan with mastercard preconditions for development are taking shape. During this time the society is buy ativan with mastercard gearing for the next stage when the preconditions are already set and buy ativan with mastercard the society is ready to develop. This stage Rostow calls the buy ativan with mastercard take-off stage – the buy ativan with mastercard GNP starts rising and the move towards industrialisation is instituted. The fourth stage is buy ativan with mastercard the drive to maturity stage. Here, the societies are already experiencing a buy ativan with mastercard rise in GDP and since the elite are benefiting strongly from buy ativan with mastercard this they would be encouraged to ensure the continuation of growth. The final stage is buy ativan with mastercard that of high consumption rates since the gains of productivity is buy ativan with mastercard distributed to the people. This stage is also characterised by the buy ativan with mastercard welfare state. This is another evolutionist account of development that, needless to buy ativan with mastercard say, is doomed to fail in capturing the development process.
Rist also examines the buy ativan with mastercard different conferences and reports that were convened and prepared in the buy ativan with mastercard name of development. There is almost no need to examine each one in itself, the buy ativan with mastercard basic theme that runs though all of them is the desire to buy ativan with mastercard write away history by not focussing on the need for a buy ativan with mastercard redefinition of development. This is exemplified by the report of the buy ativan with mastercard New International Economic Order (NIEO). The text of the buy ativan with mastercard report is a reinforcement of the dominant paradigm, it emphasised “economic growth, expansion of trade and buy ativan with mastercard increased aid by the industrial nations” as the buy ativan with mastercard solution to the problem of underdevelopment. Like many reports produced by such organisations its recommendations were not implemented. Rist says it buy ativan with mastercard is really a relief that it was not, as the recommendations would have buy ativan with mastercard been more harmful to the Third World than before, it would have buy ativan with mastercard widened the gap between the rich and poor countries as it buy ativan with mastercard still situated the source of development in the North, and the buy ativan with mastercard source would have to help the poor countries to achieve development by assisting them with aid and buy ativan with mastercard investment. Experience has shown that private investment in poor countries only come when buy ativan with mastercard the investor knows that it can maximise his profit, and this buy ativan with mastercard often to the detriment of the economy of the poor countries.
However, there is buy ativan with mastercard a report that Rist says stands out for its boldness in declaring that buy ativan with mastercard another development is possible. The Dag Hammarskjörld Foundation report extends the buy ativan with mastercard concept of development from mere economic growth to something that has buy ativan with mastercard to be born by each society out of what is unique to buy ativan with mastercard it. This means that there cannot be a universal definition of development. Another thing that buy ativan with mastercard sets it aside from all other reports is that it includes the buy ativan with mastercard industrialised countries as part of the countries that need to become developed. They need to buy ativan with mastercard review their consumption patterns. This report was simply forgotten.
The structural Adjustment Programmes of the buy ativan with mastercard 1980s is another point that is worthy of note in the buy ativan with mastercard history of development. It was a direct child of the lending activities of Northern creditors who buy ativan with mastercard lent money irresponsibly, without enough security, to Southern countries. The major impact of structural adjustment programmes was in impoverishing the buy ativan with mastercard peoples the more. It was thought that for the countries to buy ativan with mastercard be able to pay off their debt they had to, among other things, cut down on the buy ativan with mastercard involvement of government in the economy and the financing of infrastructure projects. The meaning of this buy ativan with mastercard is continued impoverishment of the population. This era was the era of the buy ativan with mastercard trickle down policies. The harm these policies did in the Third World has buy ativan with mastercard been severally studied. Considering that Rist’s mission is buy ativan with mastercard to show how contradictory development could be, and in fact is, he paid too cursory an buy ativan with mastercard attention to it. For the recency of these programmes and their failure make them scream for buy ativan with mastercard attention.
One of the buy ativan with mastercard problems with works that set out primarily to criticise a notion is buy ativan with mastercard the failure to provide an alternative. Rist’s criticisms are buy ativan with mastercard the state of the art in its field; they capture the buy ativan with mastercard very contradictions of the term, its actions and proponents. But they fail to buy ativan with mastercard provide a way out of the problem. One could try to buy ativan with mastercard understand this problem by pointing at the fact that it was not easy to buy ativan with mastercard proffer a solution where a whole industry is built around a buy ativan with mastercard concept. Rist talks about this when he pointed to the organs of United Nations, and buy ativan with mastercard the NGOs, both local and global, that are founded around the buy ativan with mastercard development concept. If one were to do away with the concept and buy ativan with mastercard its baggage what does one do with the industry? Where does one put them?
Another problem is buy ativan with mastercard about what is to be done instead of giving aid and buy ativan with mastercard other forms of assistance to poor countries. Rist’s cynicism in criticising these moves as reinforcing the buy ativan with mastercard development paradigm is understood but, practically, what is to be done? What is the alternative to this? Isn’t it buy ativan with mastercard rather better to continue with these and all its different siblings than buy ativan with mastercard to simply sit and whine, especially as the paradigm does not seem about to buy ativan with mastercard change in the nearest future? I am saying this at the peril of sounding naïve and buy ativan with mastercard simplistic but, being a citizen of the Third World, I understand that buy ativan with mastercard a long-term solution would have to take into account not just the buy ativan with mastercard immediate satisfaction of hunger but the continued survival, and by extension peaceful existence of a buy ativan with mastercard people, it would be more naïve to buy ativan with mastercard fail to act for today while being pre-occupied with thinking about tomorrow.
To answer the buy ativan with mastercard questions about what to do Rist offers three answers. One of them borrows from buy ativan with mastercard Christian Comeliau. This approach advocates economic growth and the proper integration of the buy ativan with mastercard Southern economies into the world economy, especially according to how they can buy ativan with mastercard gain from it. This is against blindly advocating the promotion of free trade. He is buy ativan with mastercard not against loans as long as the terms of the loans ensure that buy ativan with mastercard they can be paid back. He also advocates the transfer of technology to buy ativan with mastercard poor countries by multinational companies. In the classic Rist tradition he picks apart this buy ativan with mastercard proposition by questioning the intentions of the people who are supposed to buy ativan with mastercard initiate these moves. Will they be sincere enough to initiate the buy ativan with mastercard needed reforms? And even if they are what is the assurance that the programmes won’t be abandoned after the next coup d’etat, or elections? What does this leave us but a feeling of utter dejection and disillusionment? The second answer draws from buy ativan with mastercard the experiences of some grassroots movements in some poor parts of the buy ativan with mastercard world. Instead of seeking to become like the rich countries they organise to buy ativan with mastercard change the attitude and behaviour of the people, encouraging them to buy ativan with mastercard concentrate on what they posses and not on what they lack. Although Rist admits that buy ativan with mastercard a person who believes in GDP and per capita income would point to buy ativan with mastercard the material needs of these people, he concludes that what they feel would nevertheless be buy ativan with mastercard fewer discontentments as it would be if they were concentrating on their needs. But for buy ativan with mastercard how long can such islands sustain in the world where diffusion of information is buy ativan with mastercard the norm and not the exception?
The third and buy ativan with mastercard most appealing answer to the question is a total rethinking of the buy ativan with mastercard relationship between societies, drawing from the anthropology and history disciplines, as against a buy ativan with mastercard purely economic approach. These disciplines should help to study alternative models to buy ativan with mastercard achieving the state popularly referred to as development. This is because theoretical models that buy ativan with mastercard are expected to capture the reality, and reality, or alternative reality, can buy ativan with mastercard be perceived basically from historical and anthropological perspectives. This is a buy ativan with mastercard theoretical approach that does not neglect the potency of the two earlier suggestions. For Rist, the buy ativan with mastercard three form a good team, although certainly not the best.
These answers are buy ativan with mastercard good enough on the surface but considering that development is such a buy ativan with mastercard new creature that has grown in so much importance over a buy ativan with mastercard short period of time, a creature that can be likened to buy ativan with mastercard a religion, with its own priests and institutions, what is the buy ativan with mastercard assurance that these are practical answers? Just like Rist criticises the buy ativan with mastercard first answer we can almost see resistance to the development of an buy ativan with mastercard alternative paradigm. To be practical, are studies advocated by anthropologists not going to buy ativan with mastercard be funded by development agencies? Are these anthropologists not going to buy ativan with mastercard work within certain frameworks prescribed by development experts? In a buy ativan with mastercard world where research-funding agencies provide funding only for projects in their own interest, what buy ativan with mastercard would be the incentive to embark on such studies? Rist’s book is buy ativan with mastercard a classic deconstructionist text but it falls flat when it attempts to buy ativan with mastercard do more than that.

Recent Comments